Folklore and Myth Seasons & Sabbats Winter

Origin of Bakers Dozen: The Witch and St. Nicholas

In this series of articles, we present our favorite and most intriguing tales of American witches in hopes to inspire you, the reader. Some will be called witches, some shamans, and others midwives, grannies, and healers, but all are an integral part of American history and folklore and thus should be appreciated. This is the intriguing story of the origin of bakers dozen and how a witch was once a part of the American tale.

A Brief Intro to American Witches

The belief in witches dates back thousands of years and is worldwide. Here in the United States, we’ve forgotten our beginnings, and just how steeped in folklore our country really is. Folklore brought from other countries, but also folklore that originates here and is unique to this country alone. The indigenous peoples’ legends mixed with the immigrants from Europe and Africa. Some of my favorite stories of witches come from the United States—witches along the shorelines of New England, high in the Appalachian Mountains, witches living among us.

The origin of the baker's dozen involves a witch!

The Tale & Origin of the Baker’s Dozen

The story (and origin) of the Baker’s Dozen was originally written in James Kirke Paulding’s The Book of St. Nicholas in the year 1836. And it went something like this…

It Began in New Amsterdam

In the Colonial United States, a part of Manhattan (NY City) was called New Amsterdam. In this early Dutch American settlement was a baker known as Boss Boomptie or Little Baker Boomptie. This was a man who took pride in his work, but who was also trying to provide for his family in hard times. Boss Boomptie baked bread, cookies, and all manner of baked goods and sold to the public. But Boss Boomptie wasn’t necessarily a generous, kind man and someone thought he needed to be taught an important lesson.

The Origin of Bakers Dozen 13

One New Years’ Night, when Boss Boomptie was tying one on with his family and friends, there was a knock on the bakery door. His shop was closed for the holidays, but he went to answer it – he could always use the business. At the door was a haggard old woman of which Boomptie thought must’ve been a witch. She was hunched over, had a crooked nose, and leaned on a cane. She asked for a dozen Saint Nicholas cookies. He gave her twelve, and she asked him again for a dozen. He said to her, “this is a dozen. There are twelve cookies here.” The witch shook her head and informed the baker a dozen cookies meant thirteen. The other bakeries gave their customers an extra cookie to the dozen.

A Cursed Bakery

Boomptie was appalled at the woman’s remarks and sent her on her way, claiming he had to feed his family too and how dare she ask for an extra cookie. As one might expect, the baker’s luck changed the following day. Unknown assailants stole Boomptie’s goods. His bread would never rise or rose so much that it literally floated out the chimney. He suspected he had been cursed. The old witch appeared again at his door and asked for a dozen cookies. Boomptie cursed the woman and sent her on her way. Well, his luck grew worse. None of his goods baked right and his customers believed his shop was cursed. No one came to buy Boomptie’s goods.

Saint Nicholas Appears

At this point, the baker had no option but to pray. He prayed to Saint Nicholas, saint of merchants, and asked for the witch’s evil curse to be lifted. Then decided to bake another batch of Saint Nicholas cookies. And when he did…they came out of the oven perfectly! He sat them in the window of the shop, and as he looked up, there stood Saint Nicholas. Saint Nicholas reminded the baker to give to those in need, just as God gives to us. Then came another knock on the door later that night. It was the same old woman, the witch. She asked Boomptie for a dozen cookies. He happily gave her thirteen and she claimed the curse lifted. From then on, the baker always included an extra cookie to the dozen. This was the tale of the first Baker’s Dozen.

The witch and Saint Nicholas teach a baker a lesson in the origin of the baker's dozen.

A Witch Responsible for the Origin of Bakers Dozen or Saint Nicholas?

It’s interesting how Saint Nicholas knows exactly what happened between the baker and the witch…how the baker had turned the woman away when she requested an extra cookie. While they say Saint Nicholas (Santa Claus today) knows if you’ve been bad or good, I wonder whether the witch was in cahoots with Saint Nicholas. Or perhaps was the witch in the origin of the bakers dozen a shifted form of Saint Nicholas himself?

Witches often teach valuable lessons…

Witches appear in many tales from the past, often having a negative or antagonistic presence; however, they almost always represent a turn of events that teaches the main character an important lesson. In the story of the origin of the baker’s dozen, the baker needed to learn how to be generous and give to those in need. He had a greedy spirit, one that Saint Nicholas recognized and guided him to be a better person. If it wasn’t for the witch’s request and “curse”, the baker might not have ever learned the valuable lesson he did.

Origin of Bakers Dozen: The Story of the Witch and St. Nicholas

Read More Tales of American Witches and Witchcraft:


  1. Maria Hallett, the Pirate Witch of Wellfleet (Tales of American Witches, 3)

    December 16, 2019 at 6:12 pm

    […] Tales of American Witches: The Witch and the Baker’s Dozen […]

  2. Anonymous

    September 2, 2019 at 5:37 pm

    What a fantastic article! Thank you.

  3. Katherine Johnson

    August 31, 2019 at 1:06 pm

    Love this article! Thank you for this!

Leave a Reply